Monuments to a Lost Nation

by Theodore J. Karamanski

<Reprinted from Chicago History, Spring 2004>

 

While "The Alarm" and "The Signal of Peace" both portrayed the Indian as a vanishing but noble savage, the other stock image of the Native American was that of the war¬rior, dramatically represented in Chicago's public space by the Fort Dearborn Massacre. This monument memorialized the Potawatomi, Ottawa, and Chippewa attack on the inhabitants of Fort Dearborn during the War of 1812. The battle occurred among the sand dunes about a mile and a half south of the abandoned fort.

In the rout that followed, fifty three men, women, and children were killed. The bodies lay where they fell for three years after the battle. For several generations, the site was marked only by the "Massacre Tree," a dead cottonwood looming over the sand dunes. George Pullman, controversial industrialist and inventor of the railroad sleeping car, pur¬chased the site and built a mansion on the old battlefield in 1873. By the 1880s, the Prairie Avenue location had become the most elite neighborhood in Chicago and the faux castles of Gilded Age industrialists surrounded the Massacre Tree. "Methinks the place is haunted," a jour¬nalist speculated, "and a subtle spell woven of dead men's bones attracts to the scene of the massacre the pre¬sent representatives of a system doomed to vanish like that of the redskins before the advancing civilization of the new social era." As if to ward off that prospect, Pullman donated the bronze sculpture group to the Chicago Historical Society in 1893 to memorialize the dramatic incident "for posterity."

"The Fort Dearborn Massacre" (above, ca. 1912) became the most famous of Chicago's Native American memorials. It depicts Black Partridge's coming to the defense of Margaret Helm during the massacre.
"The Fort Dearborn Massacre" (above, ca. 1912) became the most famous of Chicago's Native American memorials. It depicts Black Partridge's coming to the defense of Margaret Helm during the massacre.

Follow this outside link to learn more about Chicago's Fort Dearborn

The sculpture was the work of Carl Rohl Smith, a Danish artist drawn to Chicago to complete a commission for the World's Columbian Exposition. Rohl Smith captured one of the most famed legends of the Fort Dearborn disaster, when Potawatomi Chief Black Partridge reportedly intervened to save the life of Margaret Helm, wife of an officer in the doomed garrison. The bronze group continued the "savage warrior" imagery popular in the era. Although Black Partridge is depicted as strong, commanding, and decisive, the attacking warrior figure dominates the group. His tomahawk is raised, poised to come down on the helpless white woman. His gaze, riveted on his victim, seems pitiless, and his action unstoppable; his fury overshadows Black Partridge's mercy.

The foreground figures underscore the violence of the moment: a wounded white soldier stabbed by an Indian and a white toddler, vulnerable and helpless on the ground, reaching his arms out for help. Rohl Smith included this haunting figure to represent the dozen white children killed in the battle. As if to draw the viewer to the image of the noble (instead of the savage) Indian, Rohl Smith inscribed a legend on the base of the monument: "Fort Dearborn Massacre/Black Partridge Saving Mrs. Helm."

 

Forward to the next page of this essay

Back to the previous page

Back to Online Essays

 


   Department of Anthropology
   copyright © 2002 University of Illinois, All rights reserved.
Questions and Comments to Brenda Farnell