Monuments to a Lost Nation

by Theodore J. Karamanski

<Reprinted from Chicago History, Spring 2004>

 

Genuine Great Lakes Indians still lived just a few hundred miles north of Chicago in Michigan and Wisconsin. Traditional Indian birch bark crafts and quillwork became popular with summer vacationers at Mackinac, Charlevoix, and other northern resorts. Native Americans also lived in the city itself. While McCutcheon warmed readers' hearts with his cartoons, Dr. Carlos Montezuma, outspoken critic of the Bureau of Indian Affairs, edited a national publication for Indians from his Chicago office. But by the early twentieth century, actual Native Americans ceased to register with a public engaged with what had become a popular culture icon. The Indian had gone from being the "vanishing American" to becoming an effective symbol for all of America. In multiethnic cities such as Chicago, the Indian symbolized a common, mythic past for all Americans, regardless of national origin. The Indian, by being portrayed as having no particular living heritage, could serve as America's common heritage.

American popular culture promoted a generic Indian, locked in time and space. From 1910 to 1918, Chicago's Essanay Studios helped to pioneer the film industry by producing scores of westerns. Central to the generic Indian image were the Plains Indians' feathered headdresses, the very icon used to decorate the entrance to Essanay's North Side studio. The University of Illinois football team, led by Red Grange, adopted the name the "Fighting Illini," thereby blending the heritage of a local Indian tribe with a mascot sporting a Plains costume.

Chicago's own Essanay Studios, established in 1907, produced many movies that popularized the "cowboys-and-Indians" myth, especially the "Broncho Bill" western series (above)

 

For many Chicagoans, Black Hawk is little more than a disembodied head on a hockey jersey.

Follow this link to learn more about him.

 

The Eternal Light Christian Spiritualist Church manifested the religious universalizing of the Indian. The church, an exotic blend of spiritualism, Protestantism, Catholicism, and voodoo, was founded by Leafy Anderson, one of thousands of Louisiana African Americans drawn to Chicago during the Great Migration. When Anderson learned of the story of Chief Black Hawk, the Sauk Indian who led the last military resistance to white rule in Illinois in 1832, she made him a major figure in her church as a protective, guardian spirit. The church grew quickly during the 1920s, spreading to Florida, Louisiana, and Texas. Today it continues only in New Orleans. "Black Hawk will fight your battles," Reverend Jules Anderson declared at a recent service, "because Black Hawk stands for righteousness." Most Chicagoans identify Chief Black Hawk with their National Hockey League team, established in 1926.

 

Forward to the next page of this essay

Back to the previous page

Back to Online Essays

 


   Department of Anthropology
   copyright © 2002 University of Illinois, All rights reserved.
Questions and Comments to Brenda Farnell