Voices from Stillman's Run

The events at Stillman's Run marked the point of no return for Black Hawk and the British Band. Until that moment, on May 15, 1832, no blood had yet been shed by either side in the conflict. By the end of the day, 11 soldiers and at least 5 Indians were dead. Many more deaths would follow in the coming months. Sources disagree, however, about what actually occurred along Old Man's Creek. Below, are provided a sample of conflicting reports. Some are merely inaccurate. Others willfully misrepresented by biased observers. All of them have their own agenda--though it is not always easy for us today to put our fingers on what that agenda actually is.

 

A Sampling of Voices:

 

Governor John Reynolds Issues a Second Call to Arms (5/15/1832)

An Illinois Herald Extra (5/18/1832)

A Letter from "An Officer of the Army" (5/18/1832)

An Initial Report (5/22/1832)

A Corrected Report (5/29/1832)

The Galenian Reports...and Calls for Action (5/23/1832)

Black Hawk's Account (1833)

Major Isaiah Stillman Describes his Defeat (7/10/1832)

An Eyewitness Offers Corrections (6/14/1832)

Governor Reynolds Reflects on Stillman's Run (1879)

An "Old Settler" Remembers the Battle (1874)


 

 

Back to Black Hawk: Myth and Reality


   Department of Anthropology
   copyright © 2002 University of Illinois, All rights reserved.
Questions and Comments to Brenda Farnell